Verdict
- GW10
Haaland or Evanilson for the armband
Haaland blanked on us last week. Evanilson has scored in four games in a row. One armband before the international break.
Published · Updated with result
Flipped live on FPL Shrine on 6 November, before the GW10 deadline (Friday 6 November, 18:30 UK time). One flip, recorded, never re-rolled.
Most managers' armband question this week was Haaland or an Arsenal defender, with Hull at the Emirates. We don't own Gabriel, the defender most of them were looking at. What we do own is the season's top scorer and the player more managers bought this week than anyone else. So our 50/50 was between our two forwards.
Flip 1 · CaptainHaaland or Evanilson?
The dilemma
Haaland (Man City, £15.8m) away at Forest on Saturday at 17:30, or Evanilson (Bournemouth, £6.4m) away at Ipswich on Sunday at 14:00 (UK time). Both start for us either way. Whoever gets the armband gets his points doubled, so GW10 is a straight head-to-head.
The case for Haaland
- 9 goals in 9 league games, scoring in seven of them, and City's penalty taker.
- 0.84 expected goal involvements (xGI) per 90 minutes, the best of any player in FPL with more than five games' worth of minutes.
- The higher ceiling: he's already had two 13-point weeks this season.
- He's in 79% of teams. If he scores and you've given the armband to someone else, your rank pays for it.
- The experts' pick: in FPL Mate's survey of 100 experts, he's the clear captain, and FPL Raptor's armband is on him too.
The case for Evanilson
- A goal in each of his last four league games, and 34 points across them.
- The better form: 8.5 points a game over the last month, to Haaland's 7.2.
- Haaland managed 2 points last week, in City's 1–0 home defeat to Brighton.
- The most-bought player in the game this week, by more than 750,000 managers, but still in only about one team in five. As captain, he's the differential.
Why it was genuinely 50/50
The form favours Evanilson; most of the experts favour Haaland. FPL Mate found the experts cooler on Evanilson than the wider public, and they have a point: Haaland has more goals, better underlying numbers and the penalties. But Evanilson has the form, and Haaland's last armband earned us 4 points. Haaland is the safe pick and the one with the higher ceiling; Evanilson is the in-form forward the numbers like. We couldn't separate them, so the coin did.
The flip
- A Coin's pick Haaland Man City at Forest (A)
- B Evanilson Bournemouth at Ipswich (A)
The coin said Haaland
What happened
City lost 3–1 at Forest, and Haaland played the full 90 minutes without a goal or an assist: 2 points, 4 with the armband. A second blank in a row. On Sunday, Evanilson scored again in Bournemouth's 2–1 win at Ipswich, his fifth league game in a row with a goal, and took 3 bonus points: 9 points in 84 minutes. With him as captain, we'd have had 71 instead of 64.
| Option | GW10 points |
|---|---|
| Haaland (coin's pick) | 2 |
| Evanilson | 9 |
The coin backed the league's top scorer, and the in-form forward scored instead.
The 50/50 we should have flipped
Our real mistake came before the coin. Barry scored twice and set up another in Everton's 3–1 win over Coventry: 16 points, the best in our team. We'd ruled him out of the captaincy in our research, because his form (under 5 points a game over the last month) looked too low for the armband. In hindsight, Evanilson or Barry was the 50/50 to flip. Either one would have beaten Haaland's 4.
What we didn't flip
The coin is for genuine 50/50s, so it stayed in our pocket for these:
- An Arsenal defender as captain. Hull at home made it the week to try, and plenty of managers are captaining Gabriel. We don't own him, which made the idea less appealing for us. Calafiori, who we do own, sits below Haaland in most projections and creators' rankings, with the risk of rotation the main worry. Arsenal won 1–0, and Gabriel's clean sheet got him 8 points, 16 as captain. Another one that would have beaten Haaland.
- Konsa: keep, and roll the transfer. Saliba is back from injury, and Konsa was a doubt until Arteta said on Friday: "He's fine... We took him out for precaution and for the amount of minutes he was playing." Hull at home is no time to sell him. He kept a clean sheet and made 11 defensive contributions: 8 points.
- Free Hit: save it. Our squad already has three Arsenal players at home to Hull, two Bournemouth players at Ipswich, and Haaland. The chip has more to offer on a week when our team is short. Our three Arsenal players all kept clean sheets, so no regrets there.
- Bench: Manzambi starts, Groß sits. Manzambi played about an hour in midweek, and with the break straight after Man Utd, Villa have no game to rest him for. Wrong call: Manzambi got 2 in Villa's 4–4 draw at Old Trafford, and Groß scored and kept a clean sheet on our bench for 10.
The Coin's record
- 3Right
- 6Wrong
- 2Level
- 5Long-term calls
After GW10. A head-to-head flip counts as right if the coin's pick outscored the other option, wrong if not, and level if they tied. A transfer whose new player goes straight into our team that week counts as a head-to-head too, and we keep tracking its running total on the post. Other long-term calls (chip timing, and squad moves where the new player didn't go straight into our team) play out over weeks, so we report what they've returned but leave them out of the right-or-wrong count. GW1 to GW5 were flipped pre-launch. See every Verdict.
More Verdicts
Sources
- Official FPL data: fixtures, player points, goals, expected goal involvements, prices, ownership, transfers, penalty order and form.
- 100 experts' GW10 plans (FPL Mate on YouTube)
- GW10 final decisions (FPL Raptor on YouTube)
- Arteta on Konsa (TrueAFCNews on X)
- Manzambi's minutes (SteadyFPL on X)